29 Aug 2022, 16:49

alt text


Controversy sparks over councillor question in the referendum

The opposition figures are calling for a boycott of the proposal for not being democratic
August 29, 2022


The proposals of the 2023 referendum caught even more attention after the date for the referendum was announced. One of the questions, however, has caused the most backlash: The councillor question. One of the ten proposals in the referendum asks Elthic citizens which institution should choose the European Councillor, and the two options are the president and the parliament. There isn't an option to select the councillor with an election, similar to how our current councillor, Liam Zachary, was elected.

MA Ronald Lorenzen's original proposal did have three options for this question: The president, the parliament, and the people. However, The Third Option, the largest party in both houses of the parliament, refused to vote in support of the bill unless the options were cut down to the first two. While the initial proposal passed both National Assembly and the Senate without the approval of the TTO, President Greenwich Grimwald vetoed the bill, citing the same reason and amending the bill himself before passing it again to the Senate. The bill was then approved with Grimwald's amendment, among others.

Since the Elected and Accountable Council Act of 2020 was repealed fairly recently, nothing is forcing Elthize to have elections to choose the councillor. However, some politicians believe that the power should remain in the hands of the people.

"Not having elections for a position this important is ridiculous, and there are no valid arguments for otherwise," said Matthew François, head of The Greens. "I also would like to point out that Councillor Liam Zachary has supported the repeal of the EACA, which shows that he is a power-hungry being who only cares about his seat." Lorenzen was also disappointed over the decision to remove the possibility. "Elthics should have the power to elect and power to be elected, at all opportunities. I am frustrated that Grimwald did not allow them this opportunity."

Michael Jenkins, head of Labour, has called a boycott against the proposition. Because the proposals require at least 50% voter turnout to pass, he urged party supporters not to vote to defeat them.

Other politicians, however, argue otherwise. Michelle Teel, the TTO's spokesperson, said that because the parliament and the president are a reflection of people's votes in general elections, their selection of the councillor was just as democratic as a general election. The Nationals' Francis Elvin equated the councillor role to that of a minister, meaning that it is acceptable if the president picks the councillor. Finance Minister Tobias Walters argued that councillor elections would be "useless and expensive" and condemned Jenkins' boycott call, saying that he should "know his place and not tamper with the votes of the people".

The proposal, along with other nine proposals, will be put up for a referendum on February 9 and 10, 2023.