13 Feb 2023, 15:24

alt text


Constitutional Court and Supreme Court to be merged following reform referendum

Only three of ten proposals in the reform referendum have passed
February 13, 2023


The long-awaited reform referendum finally ended this Friday after thousands of Elthics went to the polls to vote. The referendum, which was approved by President Greenwich Grimwald last August, included ten proposals that included various reforms to the country's political system. Out of ten proposals in the referendum, only three have passed. However, two of them will bring significant changes to the Elthic judiciary: The Constitutional Court and The Supreme Court will be merged into a singular court, with judges there being subject to term limits.

With the controversial decision made by the Supreme Court regarding the legality of The Unitees, as well as the Constitutional Court being perceived as going at a snail's pace on countering the decision, both courts have had their popularity ruined in recent months. Some political analysts argue that this was the catalyst which influenced the voter's decision.

"Me, and most of my colleagues that I talked to, all believe the same thing: The decisions made by either of these courts were popular, so when Elthic voters had the opportunity to abolish both, they took it," states Marion Edwards, an analyst at The Tribunal. Critics believe that these decisions will diminish the credibility of the judiciary. "Grimwald has failed the Elthic judiciary by not protecting it from populism and current politics," Chief Justice Dayo Mwangi claimed. "It is a setback. I am confident that it will recover, though."

In addition to the proposals affecting the judicial system, voters approved another idea that will shorten the time between elections from four to three years. Other interesting outcomes include a proposal to raise the number of representatives in the National Assembly from 250 to 300 being defeated by a slim majority and the failure to reinstate the position of Prime Minister due to low voter turnout. Councillor Liam Zachary, who had expressed interest in running for the position, was disappointed but hopeful: "I will continue to serve Elthics as their councillor."

A proposal to give the legislature supremacy over the executive and judicial branches of the government also failed, both by a high margin and low voter turnout. Two proposals regarding increasing diversity in the parliament also failed.

The details on how to implement the passed proposals will be discussed further in the parliament in the coming months.


Proposal no. Proposal Yes No Turnout Status
1 Do you support expanding the National Assembly by fifty seats, from 250 (two-hundred and fifty) to 300 (three hundred)? 49.8% 50.2% 53.7% FAILED
2 Do you support giving the Elthic legislature absolute supremacy over all institutions in Elthize, including executive and judiciary branches of the government? 22.7% 77.3% 42.5% FAILED
3 Do you support term limits for Supreme Court and Constitutional Court judges? 68.4% 31.6% 58.3% PASSED
4 Do you support a merger of the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court? 55.1% 44.9% 59.2% PASSED
5 Do you support having general elections every three years instead of four? 52.2% 47.8% 55.9% PASSED
6 Do you support the restoration of the position of Prime Minister, which was abolished in 2007? 45.4% 54.6% 50.4% FAILED
7 Do you support some parliament seats being reserved for minor parties to ensure diverse representation in Elthic politics? 15.6% 84.4% 50.1% FAILED
8 Do you support some parliament seats being reserved for specific demographics based on age, gender, ethnicity, or any other factors not mentioned? 9.9% 90.1% 49.8% FAILED
Proposal no. Proposal The parliament The president Turnout Status
9 Which of the following two should choose the European Councillor? 50.2% 49.8% 44.9% FAILED