
Supreme Court Strikes Down National Congress Party Whips and Legislative Alliances in McCain Vs. Thompson by 9-4
In a Civil Law Suit that has brought a shocking turn of events on how the future of Leagioan politics will be in the next few years, the Supreme Court of the Commonwealth of Leagio declared that the implementation of Legislative Campaign Alliances to be Unconstitutional. Within the same case, the Court declared that the use of Party Whips in the legislative body of Congress to be used as a harassment system to shore up votes against the free beliefs of an elected member, regardless of List or Constituency, to be Unconstitutional as well. The Court Case that brought this shocking motion of a 9-4 was between Former Senator for Muale in the Last Session of Congress John McCain and Former Conservative Reformist Senator as well as Whip Jacob Thompson. The Case begins about a few months ago before the end of the 2018-2020 Congress, where during the time of the Romain Incident happen and the Congress was voting on the Nuclear Trade Commission Act which now provides supervision on the shipping of Nuclear Material. The Conservatives felt that it was not strong enough for the safety of the Commonwealth and many voted against with Party Whips in Both Houses being instructed to ensure that the votes are their side are against the bill at the time.
However, Former Senator McClain disagreed with the party and announced that he was going to vote for the bill which resulted in a visit that would bring about McCain Vs. Thompson. Party Senate Whip Jacob Thompson visit the Office of McCain and told him that if he did not vote against the bill, then he will not be given funds for his re-election. McCain admitted to the Court that he told Whip Thompson that he can go ‘f**k himself’ and that he was still going to vote for it. After he voted for the bill, the Conservative Reform Party chairman Malanie Edwards told McCain that he was not going to be receiving funds for his run for Senate back in December from the Party by claiming that it was because of Budgetcuts. Afterwards Senator explained that in the Court Case that the Party then unofficially blacklisted him from running in any races under their name. This eventually resulted him in filing harassment against the party under the guidelines of Article 1, Section 1, Clause 2 which states that “Members of the National Congress shall be elected in general, direct, free, equal and secret elections. They shall be representatives of the whole people, not bound by orders or instructions, and responsible only to their conscience.” In addition, he filed under Article 8, section 3, Clause 20 which states that “All persons of the Commonwealth of Leagio have the right to not to be discriminated against by sexual orientation, race, color, ethnicity, history, gender, political belief, and religion.”
Eventually the suit of harassment and discrimination reached all the way to the Supreme Court of the Commonwealth, where Party Whip Thompson was required to attend as McCain is claiming harassment compensation from him along with the CRP under the guidelines of the Civil Rights Act of 1954. In this case, McCain made a compelling argument that the Whip System in Congress is unconstitutional as it violates Article 1, Section 1, Clause 2 by using a member of the Congress to compel another member to vote for a piece of legislation no matter what their conscience tells them. In addition, at the same time, McCain argued that the concept of Legislative Election Alliances like the Republicans and Free Liberalists were unconstitutional as it prevents members of the party to choose to run for a office. Although, the last bit of the argument seemed not to be as strong with the Court, the first one was the one that made an impact as the Counter-argument that the Lawyer for Whip Thompson seemed to be not as compelling. Eventually after continuous debate and questioning, the Supreme Court of the Commonwealth issued its ruling with a 9-4 vote that Party Whips were Unconstitutional and so were political legislative alliance. However, in the ruling, political parties were considered constitutional as long as they adhere to the Constitution. Chief Justice of the Supreme Court Jean Hilton in his opinion which was supported by 4 other judges stated that “Party Whips and the system that they implement to force members of Congress to adhere to party and not liberty or even the will of their constituents are a system of abusive that have more power than the actual houses of the National Congress.” Of the 3 Judges that ruled against McCain, Justice Amy Comey, who was appointed back in 1993 by President Dylan Fidalgo, dissented in her opinion, stating that the “Party Whip system was constitutional as the Constitution gave the right of political belief for the Whips to express their views to the elected members of the Congress.” At the end of the ruling, Thompson was was forced to pay McCain compensation of 45,000 Sulias for harrassment.
In addition, with the ruling in the case on stating that political legislative alliances like the Republicans were Unconstitutional, the Supreme Court gave a notice to the Free Liberalists, Republicans, and Revolutionary Front to disband their alliances with 2 weeks from now. This part of the ruling leaves many to wonder how this will affect Leagioan politics.