Act for the Condemnation of Capitalism

[Kingdom of Reitzmag]

I would like to first say that this act is disgustingly a disrespect to the peaceful coexistence of people among all ideologies. Forcing people to believe a certain ideology is not something that the EU shall meddle with and should rather prosecute those who discriminate people and even commit violence because of it. I myself am not a fan of socialism, nor capitalism, but we must not force people to believe in a certain ideology or even deprive them of their rights because of it. Only one thing should signal the EU to act, and that is if violence is already involved and used because of a simple economic and political stance.

Yuridiana Yahontov
Interim Deputy Councilor, Kingdom of Reitzmag

[Spain]

Well, I don't know what's worse: if the fillibuster former Councillor Anja Mauer made here a few days ago or this bill. Councillor Arkalis, first of all I would like to welcome you to the European Council, despite this not being the best way to start. This act doesn't just break the principles and values of the European Union when it comes to respect of all opinions and freedom of speech, but also seems very stupid and unnecesary. Capitalism, not Socialism, should be condemned, and myself as Councillor for Spain will try my best to avoid this happening. Still, I want to remark some of the false statements made on that act: "The worker is unhappy and unfree; enslaved, in a way, by the capitalist class which has achieved near-total hegemony over our European society." How on Earth could anybody here say this when no country in the European Union defends slavery? This is truly what Cllr. Trympov would call "Fake News".

Every single statement made on this bill is false, has no base or both. Still, I want to adress something very important and that's my concern about many Councillors attitudes during these days: We have seen how many are pretending to have a fight between Socialism and Communism without any explanations. And alarming statements against one side have been made by Councillors of both sides, like Councillor Granger's known sentence in the debate about the Sanction Motion on the UNSR or this act itself. That's why I ask both sides to stop making the political stage more tense, with a single purpose: keeping peace in our Union. You can have your own opinions, but this, Cllr. Arkalis, just proves me you want to establish a regime many haven't voted for. And side note of all of this, I think Councillors from the Federation of Istkalen should control theirselves a little bit more, bringing us better bills with a little bit more of sense and not making a show out of every bill they don't like or they propose. Thank you.

Donald Tusk
Deputy Speaker and Councillor for Spain

[Istkalen]

All of you, as I guessed, are puppets of the bourgeois, barely even human. All you do is regurgitate the propaganda that they force down your mouths, happily, like good puppets?

And I must say, what good puppets you are! So well-behaved, so responsive, so loyal to your masters. You have no free will, even, so devoted you are! But that is to be expected, for you are less then human. All of you are but large collections of rotting flesh controlled by the bourgeois, which are part of a vast puppet show performed before the people as to delude them further into their terrible, agonizing, servitude.

I really must commend the puppet which the bourgeois have named "Donald Tusk." It has allowed them to convey all sorts of nonsense! It has vomited up every last bit of filth that the bourgeois have fed to it! But, people of Europe, wage-slavery exists. Look it up; it does.

[BrumBrum]

I find it very sweeping and innacurate to accuse Cappitalism of being whole unethical. I am a cappitalist myself and own a huge part of one of the biggest supermarkets in Europe. We do not exploit people, we pay people fairly , share part of the profits and treat our suppliers more than fairly. We even will use our market power to force prices up if prices are below profitable levels through enforcing our standards if you want to sell through our stores but according to you we are engaging in slavery. Well I think that will be news to our workers.

There is room for an ethical cappitalism. I agree unfettered cappitalism should not be allowed for the environment, workers and human rights sakes but to ban cappitalism will not benefit the worker, it could actually make the average person poorer as efficiency drops. SME's and cooperatives are great and should be encouraged but we need the billion euro businesses for where scale is needed and if we want the best ideas and people to develop them they need to be able to profit of their ideas. Ultimately cappitalism is not bad in and of itself and markets can be part of a solution to inefficiencies if regulated to protect the vulnerable like we do in the Duchies.I would also like to point out Roscoes is far from unique in being ethical cappitalist , there are ethical cappitalist companies in all European countries.

Regardless of views on cappitalism this also tells nations how to set up their economy , that should be a local decision. Only nations and their people should be able to decide what is right for their nation beyond the protection of rights and the environment. It is not the EU's role to set a policy for economics. For these reasons I will vote against this proposal.

James Mizrachi-Roscoe, Councillour for United Duchies

[Czech Slavia]

Dear colleagues, I am of course not sure what was the intention of Councillor Arkalis, but I must admit, that I do not see such proposition as serious, for, as Councillor Arkalis surely knows, such proposition hasn't got even the slightest chance at passing through the Council. Still I want to state why I must disagree with such proposition.

We, the people of Czech Slavia, consider all nations to be equal and deserving of the same rights, such as to decide the form of government and economic system of their country for themselves. Such sovereignty must be respected by the European Council, let all member states pick their own path. I must express a pride in my country and its government, for always standing by this right, and when some called for condemnation of the revolution in Icholasen, and some even called for condemnation of the revolution in Inquista, we always said that it is the right of Nicoleizians and Inquistans to set up their own ways.

Moreover, if some system, some way, is better than the other, then the people of country going the worse way must themselves realize this and only they can change the course, it is not the job of the European Council to change their way for them. "Il n'est pas de sauveurs suprêmes
Ni Dieu, ni César, ni Tribun" and certainly not the European Council. This must be known to all socialists, and can be only ignored by ultra-left loudmouths, who try to cover up their ideological emptiness by radical statements.

I agree with what Councillor Tusk have said and I hope that from this point forward, he will stand by his own words. Just recently, in order to appease his own ego, Tusk voted against Repeal the European Commission Sanctioning Powers Act proposed by van Allen with which he agreed with. The European Commission Sanctioning Powers Act is nothing but a assault on countries that pick a different path. And Tusk, recognizing this, voted against the repeal, because it was proposed by a Councillor he disagrees with. And then he had the audacity to talk about principles. Voted against a proposition because he disagreed with the person proposing it, what a principled stance! But, I hope this is in the past and my colleague Tusk now realizes his mistake and will not make it in the future.

In conclusion, I will vote against this act, thank you.

Václav Kohout
Councillor for Czech Slavia

[Istkalen]

Councillor Kohout, the people of Europe already demand socialism. No one hears their cries for the bourgeois suffocate them. This is but the manifestation of the will of the people - the will of the people for socialism, for freedom, through, as for the creation of a symbolism of irony, through the capitalist institution of the European Council. Revolution is soon to come, spontaneously; this act is its first herald. However, I do propose the following amendment:

---

AMENDMENT I

III. Action

I. The European Union officially condemns capitalism as an economic system.

II. It requires all member-states to begin the process of abandoning it, as to prevent further misery and allow for true justice to prevail.

III. Member-states which do not comply may be punished by the European Court of Justice.

---

As for Councillor Zatoni, this legislation is hardly ideological. Capitalism, by every metric, is objectively torturous. If the banning of child marriage, of similar odiousness, is perfectly fine, then I see nothing wrong with this act.

Elspeth Arkalis
Councillor for the Federation of Istkalen

[Istkalen]

And also, to Councillor Mizrachi-Roscoe - your Roscoes sells hemp rope, does it not? If so, I must tell you, we will soon be buying it for quite a good use.

Elspeth Arkalis
Councillor for the Federation of Istkalen

[Inimicus]

"No. Just no."

Nicholas Benfield
Empire of Inimicus

[BrumBrum]

"If you want to know why the Duchies is cracking down on left wing extremism and your kind you need only look at yourself Ms Arkalis. Your comment about rope is disgusting given the many innocent people killed by terrorism from your extreme ideology. This only sows more discord and violence insinuating violence is okay. You do nothing to help shed the image of your government as supportive of terrorism and extremism even if your government doesn't have institutional links to terrorism.

James Mizrachi-Roscoe, Councillour for United Duchies

[Istkalen]

Cllr Mizrachi-Roscoe, I don't understand. I was just inquiring as to whether your Roscoes sells hemp rope, for I think I have found a new and revolutionary use for it. How this is disgusting or related to murder I do not know.

But in any case, we all live in a great bourgeois dictatorship, and you, of course, are one of its administrators! Marvelous job, marvelous job! Certainly much better than the bourgeois of Istkalen, who to me seem complete idiots, every single one, with no regard for human life!

But in any case, everything said in this act is objectively true. None of it is extreme in the slightest; it is a collection of facts brought together as to make a coherent and obvious argument, and from that a condemnation of the odious ideology that plagues us all and that you - flesh-puppets and bourgeois dictators of this chamber - you wish so eagerly to defend.

[Montenbourg]

This is not a serious proposition...

Emma Granger
Councillor for Montenbourg

[Fremet]

The debate has ended. We will now vote on Amendments, of which one has been proposed:

AMENDMENT I

III. Action

I. The European Union officially condemns capitalism as an economic system.

II. It requires all member-states to begin the process of abandoning it, as to prevent further misery and allow for true justice to prevail.

III. Member-states which do not comply may be punished by the European Court of Justice.

Voting will end 17 April 2021 at 17h00 GMT.

---

I vote FOR Amendment I.

Charles Michel
Council Speaker and Councilor for Fremet

[Spain]

I vote FOR Amendment I.

Donald Tusk
Deputy Speaker and Councillor for Spain

[Nofoaga]

I vote AGAINST amendment I

Mrs. Paul-Gabrielle Muzhare
EU councilor for the Republic of Nofoaga

[Fayrrendel]

I vote AGAINST admendment I

Tony Odhinazen
EU Councilor, Ruthund

[Istkalen]

I vote FOR Amendment I.

Milrakas Ikoszer
Councillor for the Federation of Istkalen

[Fremet]

With 3 votes FOR, 2 votes AGAINST, and no Abstentions, Amendment I has PASSED.
The original legislation has been updated to reflect the amendment made.

Final voting begins NOW and ends 23 April 2021 at 12h00 GMT.

---

On behalf of the Republic of Fremet, I vote AGAINST this motion.

Charles Michel
Council Speaker and Councilor for Fremet

[Inimicus]

Naturally, the Empire of Inimicus votes AGAINST this motion.

[Montenbourg]

On behalf of the Kingdom of Montenbourg, I vote AGAINST this motion.

Emma Granger
Councillor for Montenbourg

[Nofoaga]

On behalf of the Republic of Nofoaga, I vote AGAINST this motion.

Mrs. Paul-Gabrielle Muzhare
EU Councilor for the Republic of Nofoaga