21 Sept 2021, 23:00

I cannot thank Comrade Tilkanas enough for proposing this incredibly important and vital piece of legislation, as well as for their ongoing perseverance in ensuring that the finest version of this Act is passed so that the workers of Europe are best protected and emancipated. It is absolutely imperative that workers have legally-encoded rights to their own unions and bargaining power. While this Act may require further amendments, I see no reason why it should be defeated, and I hope that it is eventually passed.

I only have three recommendations to improve this piece of legislation.

Firstly, the right to recourse mentioned in Section II Clause VII probably needs a corresponding definition in the definitions section. The term 'recourse' can mean various things, specifically when talking about the right to recourse in legalese terms, and so it opens up that specific clause to a lot of open-ended interpretation. A short yet precise definition could remedy this.

Secondly, Section II Clause IV is incredibly open-ended, and essentially insinuates that labour unions should be free of absolutely all outside interference, which would also include the state and the state's own laws concerning labour unions and union codes. While I wholeheartedly support the autonomy of unions, I think it is reasonable that the state might have labour codes which pertain to the governance and administration of unions, such as a gender quotas for boards - just as an example. This specific clause also clashes with other clauses in the Act, most notably Section III Clause III. Section III Clause III is basically the same version of this clause, but respects national law. Since Section III Clause III exists anyway, and is a better version of this clause, I think Section II Clause IV is basically superfluous and should be removed or be amended to be more congruent.

Thirdly, Section II Clause VI and Section III VII are carbon copies of each other. Having them both is superfluous. The one in Section III should probably be removed.

With these comments in mind, I wholeheartedly give this Act my approval.

Bp. Karinn Lallana
Councillor for Inquista