Petitioner: Gertrude Echteran
Petitionee: Premier Commissioner Walter Cocx
Reason for Petition: The Premier Commissioner, under the European Commission Sanctioning Powers Act 2020, submitted a sanction motion against Istkalen without the recorded approval of any other Commissioner, thus violating said act, which requires a unanimous Commission in order to submit a Sanction Motion to the Council. This occurred twice before, with the submission of two sanction motions against the UNSR, neither of which gained the explicit approval of any other Commissioner, save for the first, in which Commissioner Birdane stated that she would support a motion against the UNSR that would allow for the survival of the people of the UNSR, while never giving her agreement to any of the drafts proposed by Commissioner Cocx.
Evidence: Commission debate regarding Sanction Motions; European Commission Sanctioning Powers Act.
Remedy: The immediate withdrawal of any present Sanction Motion acts made without the approval of the whole of the Commission
Gertrude Echteran withdraws her motion against the Premier Commissioner.
The Republic of Istkalen withdraws its case against the United Duchies.
Petitioner(s): The Government of the Kingdom of Reitzmag
Petitionee(s): The United Dominions of Icholasen
Reason for petition: incitment of violence and terrorism
Relevant part(s) of the Constitution / legislation:
Evidence: Destruction of Buildings occupied by Reitzmics in Copala City by Nicolezians fleeing to the United Duchies with the use of bombs.
Remedy: Compensation in cash for total cost of damages
@Kingdom-of-Reitzmag The petition of the Government of the Kingdom of Reitzmag against the United Dominions of Icholasen has been accepted. A solicitor representing the petitioner is hereby summoned to the Court.
ECoJ Clerk of Court
Petitioner(s): Keeva Donohue Cèamp
Petitionee(s): Strathaen Government
Reason for petition: Breach of ARTICLE V. THE UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS Section IV. Freedom from Slavery by forcing all citizens to provide free labour to community programmes under threat of fines or imprisonment. Also of Section "XX. Right to Democratic Governance
Relevant part(s) of the Constitution / legislation: ARTICLE V. THE UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS Section IV. Freedom from Slavery
Evidence: http://nseuropeanunion.com/topic/1020/community-duty-programme
Petitioner(s): Orrin McGill Sgot
Petitionee(s): Mennrimiak Government
Reason for petition:I am a reformed Breizhighist Strathen who was kicked out of the country based on my nationality and culture. This is a violations of protections against population transfer or forcible movement based on innate characteristics of a group including: a group's culture, religion, sexual orientation, political beliefs or other protected statuses as outlined in the UDoHR . The government have kicked out a whole nationality on pretense of extremism when there is no evidence all are extreme , essentially punishing a whole nationality for the actions of a government leader who was extreme and has refused to remove measures when a new government was elected that no longer is pushing for the policies of the old government. This is clear discrimination of a group based on nationality and culture both protected characteristics.I seek the overturn of this ban and travel ban so that no one is denied unless there is evidence the individual shows threat of extremism or threat to national security
Relevant part(s) of the Constitution / legislation: III. Population transfer, defined as the forcible movement, imposed by an authority, of a large group of people from one region to another, for reasons relating to innate characteristics of a group including: a group's culture, religion, sexual orientation, political beliefs or other protected statuses as outlined in the UDoHR, is recognized as a violation of the right of freedom of movement and is thus prohibited.
Evidence:http://nseuropeanunion.com/topic/340/mennrimiak-news-media/31
Remedy:Removal of discriminatory law and restablishment of visas that were unfairly cancelled
@Kingdom-of-Reitzmag the case Keeva Donohue Cèamp v. Strathae is hereby REJECTED on the following grounds:
ECoJ Clerk of Court
Petitioner(s): Park Yeon-mi
Petitionee(s): Government of Strathae
Reason for petition: Breach of ARTICLE V. THE UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS:
Relevant part(s) of the Constitution / legislation: ARTICLE V. THE UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS Section IV. Freedom from Slavery
Evidence: http://nseuropeanunion.com/topic/1020/community-duty-programme
Remedy: Cease and Desist Order to the Government of Strathae
Petitioner(s): the Government of the Republic of Istkalen
Petitionee(s): the Joint Transitional Authority for Istkalen
Reason for petition: During the short war, the Reitzmo-Vardic Coalition, in an attempt to procure surrender, intentionally attempted, successfully to destroy civilian areas without combatants or military importance - facts known well to them - in an attempt to procure the surrender of Istkalen, later discovered to be not for national safety but rather for the purpose of economic exploitation. Because that which was destroyed and those who died in this bombardment were not of military importance of combatants, nor were the results of the bombardments an example of "collateral damage," this constitutes arbitrary deprivation of life. Added to this, there is also evidence of this being a premeditated move, meaning that the Reitzmic armed forces had previously investigated the areas destroyed, found them to be without combatants or military importance, and decided it a good idea to fire upon them.
Following this, Reitzmic soldiers invaded, temporarily, every building in the zone then occupied, violating wantonly many people's homes for reasons that remain unknown. We will, however, not press charges regarding this, as it may have been necessary.
This being the fault of the Reitzmo-Vardic Coalition, now represented as the J-TAI, we find it fit to be included.
During the occupation, Istkalen itself was forcibly abolished by the Joint Transitional Authority in Istkalen, a body whose goal it was to impose a manifesto, which continues to remain unknown to everyone but the members of the J-TAI, on Istkalen without the consultation of the people of Istkalen, establishing a legislature that initially had no Istkalener representatives and continues to have none. Even if it did, they would constitute a minority, violating the principle that government must be based on the will of the people.
We view the abolition as illegal, as it constituted an arbitrary deprivation of citizenship and nationality, and thus of rights as well. Indeed, immediately afterward, the J-TAI attempted to persecute journalists alleged to be spreading "misinformation," a clear violation of the right to freedom of expression. At the same time, it severely restricted movement out and in from Istkalen, requiring special exemption from the J-TAI itself to leave, effectively depriving the vast majority of Istkaleners from the right to freedom of movement.
On top of this, under the J-TAI, Istkalen has no unbiased court system. This was best illustrated by the ability of the J-TAI appointed foreign legislature to airily dismiss hundreds of allegations of rape and violence on the part of occupiers at once, without investigation. We do not say that these allegations are true, but we were investigating them; the J-TAI, however, put a stop to this, very suspiciously. This is again, a violation of rights.
Relevant part(s) of the Constitution / legislation: Article V, Section III; Article V, Section VIII; Article V, Section XIII; Article V, Section XV; Article V, Section XVIII; Article V, Section XX
Evidence:
http://nseuropeanunion.com/topic/899/operation-rule-britannia/13
http://nseuropeanunion.com/topic/899/operation-rule-britannia/11
http://nseuropeanunion.com/topic/915/official-bulletin-joint-transitional-authority-for-istkalen/2
Remedy:
Extradition of General Peter Renwalt, among other identified war criminals, to stand trial for war crimes in Istkalen. Handover and reparation for all stolen property; renegotiation of present means of reparation for war damages caused by the Istkalener state. Release of state officials imprisoned by the J-TAI.
The European Court of Justice thanks all petitioners for their cases, and apologises for the delay in processing. Nevertheless, the Court has decided the following:
Benjamin STEYN
Chief Justice of the ECoJ
Petitioner(s): Marine Marchand
Petitionee(s): the Kingdom of Reitzmag
Reason for petition: On the 7th of March, 2021, I was arrested by security forces of the Kingdom of Reitzmag for alleged crimes I committed on Nicoleizian soil, shortly before the suspension of autonomy, on the charge of "state larceny," which does not exist in Nicoleizian law. I was, for this crime, sentenced to life imprisonment, unusual and harsher in comparison to the sentences given to others who committed crimes similar to mine - rebellion, the equivalent to Reitzmic "state larceny," usually does not carry a life sentence. While I understand that violence did occur as a result of my crime, I was not responsible for this violence, nor was the state which I governed at the time - it was entirely spontaneous violence caused by the people of Bomballey at the time. This constitutes primarily a violation of my freedom from presumed or retroactive guilt, as I was tried for a crime which did not exist in the territory in which I was committing it in at the time, and furthermore my right to legal remedy, as my rights were violated as a result of actions on Nicoleizian soil and yet I was unable to access a competent Nicoleizian tribunal due to the actions of the Reitzmic government. The unusuality of a life sentence may also be a cruel, unusual, and inhumane punishment.
Relevant part(s) of the Constitution / legislation: Article V, Section XI, clause II; Article V, Section VIII; Article V, Section V, clause IV.
Evidence:
I. The Treaty of Buckingham, which established Nicoleizian sovereignty over the area in which I committed the alleged crime in question
II. Reitzmic suspension of Nicoleizian sovereignty over the area in question, which occurred after I committed the alleged crime:
III. My arrest by Reitzmic authorities for declaring the independence of Bomballey while it was still a Nicoleizian territory, and thus not subject to Reitzmic law - "state larceny" under Reitzmic law, a crime which exists nowhere else, especially not under Nicoleizian law.
IV. My sentencing to life imprisonment by Reitzmic authorities for the crime of "state larceny" committed on Nicoleizian soil
Remedy: Overturning of the original Reitzmic sentence; extradition from Reitzmag as to stand trial, before a Nicoleizian court, for the crimes I likely committed in the territory of Icholasen.
Petitioner(s): Imperial Consul Simge Galanth of the Empire of Inimicus
Petitionee(s): the Government of the Clan Democracy of Strathae
Reason for petition: violation of the right to privacy, freedom of conscience, freedom of speech, freedom of association
Relevant part(s) of the Constitution / legislation: Universal Declaration of Human Rights Articles XII, XVII, XVIII, XIX
Evidence:
Official proclamation of the Strathae Foreign Office restricting the singing of popular anthems, on pain of attendance bans and movement restrictions, and enforced by private investigators and contra-constitutional internet measures.
Repeated media accusations by free journalists of repression and state-sanctioned tyranny in the Clan Democracy of Strathae
Media reports detailing the Strathae government's absolute control over the opinions and expressive rights of its citizens
Remedy: immediate revocation of the association between UEFA and Strathae sports associations; monetary fines to Strathae sports organisations; imprisonment of those at the head of Strathae sports organisations.
Petitioner(s): Devon Albert, The Nationals' candidate in the 2022 councillor elections in Elthize
Petitionee(s): The Government of The State of Elthize & Greenwich Grimwald, President of The State of Elthize
Reason for the petition: The recall of Liam Zachary from the position of Councillor for Elthize
Relevant part(s) of the Constitution/legislation: Section XX, Clause I and III of The Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Section XX. Right to Democratic Governance
I. Everyone has the right to take part in the government of his country, directly or through freely chosen representatives.
III. The will of the people shall be the basis of the authority of government.
Remedy: Liam Zachary returns to his position as Councillor for The State of Elthize and serves until the next general election of the country.
The ECoJ has voted (3-1) to reject the petition of Devon Albert.
Juan Luis López Guerra
Chief Justice of the ECoJ
@Kingdom-of-Reitzmag the case Keeva Donohue Cèamp v. Strathae is hereby REJECTED on the following grounds:
ECoJ Clerk of Court
The Kingdom of Spain